A lawyer for HRM told the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia that the “rules” for disposing of a former school building were only ever meant to be guidelines.

On the second day of a review of the St. Patrick’s-Alexandra School sale, Jocelyn Campbell said the policy would have been made into a law if it was meant to be legally binding.

Community groups say the sale violated HRM policies because the property was sold for less than market value and there was no community consultation.

Campbell pointed out that market value is not the same as the appraised value, noting that Jono Developments offered $3 million for the property, “as-is” – $2 million more than the as-is appraised value.

The non-profit groups cited an appraisal of $4.3 million, which Campbell said included a zoning change and development agreement.

Campbell also noted that the official policy for disposal of surplus property wasn’t followed on 16 prior sales in the last 12 years, so it’s unreasonable to expect a different procedure this time around.

Outside court, Rev. Rhonda Britton said it makes no sense for the city to set a policy – but then never abide by it.

Lawyers for Jono Developments president Joe Metlege will present their arguments for upholding the sale on Friday.